Brown to the ground for me- first winter in zone 5b. Not sure if it's still alive or not, but April 19 2025 it's completely brown. I'll wait and see.
Acquired around June 2024 as a bareroot from Tractor Supply- had a decent first summer and was in bloom pretty much until fall. Struggled a bit with some blackspot and yellowing leaves- but not terribly. Had a really nice smell and it was probably my favorite red rose besides Munstead Wood- which gets preference for sentimental reasons.
Brown to the ground for me in zone 5b. Not really a surprise as it's rated for zone 7- but I enjoyed it for the season and bought on bare root clearance at Home Depot. I'll update if it actually grows again- but as of April 19 it looks pretty gone.