PhotoComments & Questions 
Vineyard Song  rose photo courtesy of Woodbury, Celeste
Discussion id : 40-886
most recent 30 APR 10 SHOW ALL
 
Initial post 30 NOV 09 by Cass
Hardy in Zone 4b?
REPLY
Reply #1 of 3 posted 30 NOV 09 by celestialrose
This was brand-new for me this year.....so unfortunately I cannot say whether
'Vineyard Song' will be hardy (or not) here in zone 4b just yet.
I do grow many roses which aren't rated as hardy here and every spring after
cutting back winterkill I am left with just a few inches of plant. That being said,
most roses, if healthy, rebound quickly and will become a decent size and will bloom nicely. I always plant the graft down deeply but I no longer am a slave to winter protection. I have way too many roses now! Its 'survival of the fittest' out there.

I am always adding new roses each year.....sorry I couldn't give a 'hardiness' report on this one.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 3 posted 30 NOV 09 by Cass
Thanks. I'll be surprised if it manages in Zone 4b. Keep us posted.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 3 posted 30 APR 10 by celestialrose
I wanted to give an update on this rose's winter hardiness for me after its first winter
here in zone 4b. Granted, this past winter was on the 'mild' side for us.....more like
a zone 5 winter....but with no winter protection other than mulch at the base of the
plant it survived fine with only minimal (tip) dieback. I was expecting more dieback
because we didn't have our usual snow cover and the plant was exposed most of
the winter. It did just fine.
Celeste
REPLY
© 2025 HelpMeFind.com